Food & Herbal Plant Extract Ingredient Manufacturer Malaysia.
Deep purple spray-dried botanical extract powder heaped in a shallow dish beside fresh elderberries and a sealed foil sachet
Encapsulation yield at the drier outlet says little about what survives a tropical warehouse. The deciding properties are the glass transition and water activity.
ReviewWall materials judged on storage, not yieldClimatic zone IVb: 30 °C, 75% RHTesting sequence proposed

Author: Ts. Ng Kuak Ping (ORCID 0009-0009-8634-2207), Research and Development Department, Bionutricia Manufacturing Sdn Bhd, Malaysia

Correspondence: ng@bionutricia.com

Article type: Narrative review. Running title: Spray-dried botanical powders in hot humid markets.

Commercial interest: The author owns the Bionutricia group, a manufacturer of spray-dried botanical extracts and nutraceutical products. No product of the author’s company is evaluated in this review. See the disclosure section.

Abstract

Spray drying with carbohydrate, gum and protein wall materials is the dominant route for converting botanical extracts into powders for supplements and functional foods. Most studies, and recent reviews of wall materials, judge success by encapsulation yield, encapsulation efficiency and particle morphology measured immediately after drying. For products sold in hot and very humid regions, where stability testing is performed at 30 degrees Celsius and 75 per cent relative humidity, these measures say little about shelf life. This narrative review reframes wall-material selection around storage performance. It explains how water sorption and the glass transition determine stickiness, caking and chemical degradation; compares maltodextrins, gum arabic, starches and proteins by their stability-relevant properties, including halal and supply considerations; and examines what encapsulation efficiency, moisture content and flow indices do and do not show. A recent elderberry study is used as a worked example: its preferred powder had a Carr index of about 27 and a Hausner ratio of 1.38, classed as poor flow by pharmacopoeial criteria, and no storage test was performed. A testing sequence combining sorption isotherms, glass transition measurement and climatic-zone storage in the final pack is proposed, with a minimum reporting standard.

Keywords: spray drying; wall materials; maltodextrin; gum arabic; glass transition; water activity; storage stability; climatic zone IVb; powder flow; botanical extracts

1. Introduction

Spray drying converts a liquid feed into a dry powder in seconds, is continuous and inexpensive, and is the most widely used encapsulation process in the food industry [1,2]. For botanical extracts it serves two purposes: it turns a perishable liquid into a powder that can be filled into sachets, capsules and tablets, and, when a wall material is added, it surrounds labile constituents such as anthocyanins and other polyphenols with a protective matrix [3,4]. The choice of wall material, most often maltodextrin, gum arabic, modified starch or a protein, is the central formulation decision [2].

Two recent publications illustrate how this decision is usually evaluated. Díaz-Montes reviewed five years of spray-drying studies and organised them by wall material, emphasising encapsulation yield, encapsulation efficiency and capsule morphology [2]. Mutavski and colleagues spray-dried an ultrasound-assisted extract of black elderberry pomace with six ratios of maltodextrin to gum arabic and selected a 40:60 blend as optimal on the basis of yield, retention of phenolics and powder flow [5]. Both are valuable, and both share a limitation that is common in the field: the powders are characterised at the end of drying, while the properties that decide commercial success, namely retention of actives, flowability and absence of caking over a shelf life of two or more years, are assumed rather than measured. Mutavski and colleagues acknowledge this and call for storage studies [5].

The limitation matters most in hot and humid climates. Malaysia and its neighbours fall within climatic zone IVb, for which the regional stability guideline specifies long-term testing at 30 degrees Celsius and 75 per cent relative humidity and accelerated testing at 40 degrees Celsius and 75 per cent relative humidity [6]. Indonesia adopted the same reference conditions for health supplements in 2025 [7]. Amorphous spray-dried powders are hygroscopic and their physical state is highly sensitive to water and temperature [8,9]. A powder that performs well at the end of a laboratory run in a temperate country may become sticky, cake and lose its actives in a tropical warehouse.

This review therefore asks how wall materials and spray-drying conditions should be chosen and evaluated when the goal is storage stability in hot and humid markets. The perspective is that of a manufacturer of botanical extract powders and finished supplements in a zone IVb country.

2. Methods of literature selection

This is a narrative review. The two source publications [2,5] were read in full. Additional literature was identified through searches of the Europe PubMed Central database and publisher websites using combinations of the terms spray drying, wall material, carrier agent, maltodextrin, gum arabic, glass transition, water sorption, stickiness, caking, storage stability and anthocyanin, with priority given to studies that measured glass transition, sorption behaviour or storage stability, and to regulatory guidance on stability testing. Bibliographic details were verified against the Crossref registry. No quantitative synthesis was attempted.

3. Why water and temperature govern powder stability

3.1. The glassy state

Spray drying removes water so quickly that dissolved sugars, acids and polymers do not crystallise but solidify as an amorphous glass. In the glassy state molecular mobility is very low, so physical and chemical changes are slow. When the temperature exceeds the glass transition temperature, the matrix becomes rubbery, viscosity falls by orders of magnitude, and stickiness, collapse, caking, crystallisation, loss of volatiles, browning and oxidation accelerate [8,10]. Stability during storage therefore requires that the storage temperature remain below the glass transition temperature of the powder at its actual water content.

3.2. Water as a plasticiser

Water lowers the glass transition temperature strongly. The relationship between water content and glass transition is commonly described by the Gordon–Taylor equation, and the relationship between water content and water activity by sorption isotherm models such as the Guggenheim–Anderson–de Boer equation [10–12]. Combining the two gives a critical water activity and a critical water content, the values at which the glass transition temperature falls to the storage temperature. A powder stored above its critical water activity will become rubbery even if it was glassy when packed. Tonon and colleagues used this approach for spray-dried açaí juice with four carriers and showed that water adsorption and glass transition differed markedly between carriers [11].

3.3. Stickiness and caking

Botanical extracts often contain sugars and organic acids of low molecular weight, which have low glass transition temperatures and make spray drying difficult: the particles stick to the dryer wall, yields fall, and the powder may cake later [13]. Stickiness in the dryer and caking in storage arise when particle surfaces become rubbery, allowing liquid bridges and sintering between particles [13,14]. Sticky-point temperatures can be measured directly, for example by rheometry, and are typically somewhat above the glass transition temperature [15]. Adding high-molecular-weight carriers raises the glass transition temperature of the mixture and is the main reason why carriers improve both drying yield and storage behaviour [9,13,16]. In freeze-dried mango, maltodextrin raised the glass transition temperature and reduced caking, and the plant pulp itself reduced hygroscopicity [16].

3.4. Chemical degradation

Molecular mobility also governs chemical reactions. In spray-dried açaí powders stored for 120 days, both higher temperature (35 compared with 25 degrees Celsius) and higher water activity (0.529 compared with 0.328) accelerated anthocyanin degradation, which followed first-order kinetics, and maltodextrin of dextrose equivalent 10 gave the best anthocyanin retention among four carriers [17]. In grape marc extract powders, anthocyanin degradation in accelerated tests at 40 and 60 degrees Celsius also followed first-order kinetics and depended on the carrier [18]. These data show that the carrier affects not only how much active survives drying but how fast it is lost afterwards.

4. Wall materials through a stability lens

Table 1. Wall materials compared by properties relevant to storage in hot and humid conditions.

Wall material Effect on glass transition and stickiness Hygroscopicity Other functions Practical constraints
Maltodextrin, low dextrose equivalent (about 10) Raises glass transition strongly; improves drying yield Lower than high dextrose equivalent grades Best anthocyanin retention among four carriers for açaí Poor emulsifier; fine powders with poor flow when used alone
Maltodextrin, high dextrose equivalent (about 20) Weaker effect Higher water adsorption More soluble Higher caking risk in humid storage
Gum arabic Raises glass transition; good film former Higher than maltodextrin Emulsifies oils and lipophilic actives High cost; check halal and supplier certification
Native starch (for example tapioca) Moderate Lowest water adsorption among four açaí carriers Low cost Poor solubility in water
Modified (octenyl succinic) starch Raises glass transition Moderate Emulsifier; gum arabic replacement Regulatory status of modified starch varies by market
Proteins (whey, soy, pea) Surface film reduces stickiness even at low levels Moderate High drying yield at low carrier ratios Polyphenol binding; allergen labelling; halal source for whey
Gelatin Good barrier and film former Moderate Traditional encapsulant Mammalian sources raise halal issues; fish gelatin is an alternative

4.1. Maltodextrins

Maltodextrins are inexpensive, bland, highly soluble and form amorphous matrices [2,5]. Their dextrose equivalent is the key specification: maltodextrins of lower dextrose equivalent have higher average molecular weight and therefore raise the glass transition temperature of mixtures more effectively, whereas higher dextrose equivalent grades are more hygroscopic [9,11]. In açaí powders, maltodextrin of dextrose equivalent 20 adsorbed more water than dextrose equivalent 10, and the lower grade gave better anthocyanin stability [11,17]. Maltodextrin alone has poor emulsifying capacity, which limits its use with oily extracts.

4.2. Gum arabic

Gum arabic is an arabinogalactan–protein complex with good emulsifying and film-forming properties, valuable for extracts containing essential oils or lipophilic actives [2,5]. It is more hygroscopic than maltodextrin [5,11] and considerably more expensive, so its use must be justified economically [5]. Blends with maltodextrin are widely used to balance emulsification against cost and hygroscopicity [5].

4.3. Starches and modified starches

Native starches are poorly soluble, but tapioca starch adsorbed the least water among four carriers for açaí powder [11]. Chemically modified starches, such as octenyl succinic anhydride starches, combine emulsification with lower cost than gum arabic and are common in industrial flavour encapsulation [1,19]. Their regulatory status as modified starches must be checked in each market.

4.4. Proteins

Whey, soy and pea proteins form films at the droplet surface during drying, migrate to the particle surface and reduce stickiness [1,20]. Small amounts of protein have been shown to improve powder recovery even from sticky sugar-rich feeds [20]. In grape marc extract, whey protein isolate gave higher drying yield than maltodextrin at much lower carrier ratios [18]. Proteins can, however, bind polyphenols, which may change their release and analytical recovery, and they introduce allergen declarations.

4.5. Halal, sourcing and labelling constraints

For products sold to Muslim consumers, who form the majority in Malaysia, Indonesia and Brunei, wall materials must be halal. Gelatin, a classic encapsulant, is mostly derived from porcine and bovine sources, and fish gelatin is a recognised alternative with different gelling and barrier properties [21]. Plant-based carbohydrates and proteins avoid this issue but require certification of processing aids. Cost, supply security and clean-label perception also influence the choice; the elderberry authors noted the relatively high cost of gum arabic as a scale-up consideration [5].

5. What the usual metrics do and do not show

Table 2. Common metrics for spray-dried botanical powders: what they show and what they miss.

Metric What it shows What it does not show
Encapsulation (process) yield Recovery of solids in the dryer; stickiness at that scale Storage behaviour; strongly scale-dependent
Encapsulation efficiency (total versus theoretical) Retention of active through drying Whether active is inside or on the surface; retention over time
Encapsulation efficiency (surface versus total) Fraction protected by the wall Retention over time
Moisture content Water removed in drying Physical state; water activity differs between carriers at equal moisture
Water activity Driving force for moisture exchange and reactions Physical state unless related to glass transition
Glass transition temperature at packed water activity Margin between physical state and storage temperature Chemical reactions that occur even in the glass
Carr index and Hausner ratio Flow and compressibility of fresh powder Flow after storage; must be read against pharmacopoeial scale
Morphology by microscopy Shape, surface, cracks Quantitative stability

5.1. Yield and efficiency

Encapsulation yield, the fraction of fed solids recovered as powder, mainly reflects stickiness and losses in the laboratory dryer and is strongly scale-dependent. Encapsulation efficiency is defined inconsistently: some studies compare the total active in the powder with the theoretical content, while others distinguish surface from encapsulated active by washing the particles with a solvent that does not dissolve the wall [2,19]. Only the second definition measures encapsulation in the strict sense. In the elderberry study, efficiency was the ratio of quantified to theoretical content, and the carrier-to-extract ratio is described differently in the methods and in the efficiency calculation, which makes the efficiency values difficult to interpret [5]. Neither definition predicts retention during storage.

5.2. Moisture content without water activity

Moisture content alone does not determine stability, because the relationship between moisture and water activity differs between carriers [11]. In the elderberry study, the maltodextrin-rich powders held more moisture than the gum-arabic-rich ones, contrary to their expected hygroscopicity, which the authors attributed to process factors [5]. Water activity and the corresponding glass transition temperature would have shown whether these differences matter for storage.

5.3. Flow indices

The Carr compressibility index and Hausner ratio are useful screening tools, but their interpretation should follow pharmacopoeial scales. According to the United States Pharmacopeia, a compressibility index of 26 to 31 per cent and a Hausner ratio of 1.35 to 1.45 indicate poor flow, and values of 38 per cent or more and above 1.60 indicate very, very poor flow [22]. The elderberry powders ranged from a Carr index of 39.9 and Hausner ratio of 1.66 for maltodextrin alone to about 27 and 1.37 for gum-arabic-rich blends [5]. The preferred blend was therefore a clear improvement on maltodextrin alone, but its flow remains classed as poor. This is typical of fine spray-dried particles, which were about 2 micrometres in this study [5], and has practical consequences for sachet filling and tableting. Flow measured on freshly dried powder may also deteriorate on storage as surfaces absorb moisture.

Table 3. Flow of black elderberry powders reported by Mutavski and colleagues, classified against the United States Pharmacopeia scale.

Powder (maltodextrin:gum arabic) Carr index (per cent) Hausner ratio Pharmacopoeial class
SD 1 (100:0) 39.9 1.66 Very, very poor
SD 2 (80:20) 35.8 1.56 Very poor
SD 3 (60:40) 29.9 1.43 Poor
SD 4 (40:60), selected as optimal 27.8 1.38 Poor
SD 5 (20:80) 27.5 1.38 Poor
SD 6 (0:100) 27.2 1.37 Poor

Flow values from Mutavski et al. [5]; classification after United States Pharmacopeia general chapter 1174 [22].

6. Handling and dosage-form requirements

Fine, cohesive, hygroscopic powders are difficult to dose accurately in sachet and capsule filling and to compress into tablets. Several approaches are available. Increasing particle size through larger nozzles, higher feed solids or fluidised-bed agglomeration improves flow and reduces dust; agglomerated fruit powders have been studied specifically for storage stability [23]. Blending with flow aids and with less hygroscopic excipients improves handling, but dilutes the active. Granulation of the spray-dried powder for tableting must avoid water-based processes that would plasticise the matrix; dry granulation or non-aqueous binders are preferable. Processing rooms in tropical plants should be humidity-controlled, because exposure of an open powder to ambient air at high humidity during weighing and filling may exceed its critical water activity within minutes to hours.

7. Packaging

Packaging determines how much moisture reaches the powder during its shelf life. The regional stability guideline distinguishes impermeable containers, for which humidity is not specified, from semi-permeable ones, which must be tested at 75 per cent relative humidity [6]. For hygroscopic botanical powders, aluminium-laminate sachets, alu–alu blisters and sealed containers with desiccant are the practical options, and the choice should be based on the critical water activity of the powder and the water vapour transmission of the pack over the intended shelf life. Bulk ingredient packaging, typically lined drums or bags, also needs a moisture barrier sized for warehouse conditions. Stability studies should be performed in the final commercial pack.

8. A testing sequence for hot and humid markets

The principles above lead to a practical testing sequence. During formulation development, sorption isotherms and glass transition temperatures at several water activities identify the critical water activity of each candidate powder at 30 degrees Celsius, the zone IVb storage temperature [11,12]. Candidates whose critical water activity is below the water activity achievable in production and packing should be rejected or reformulated, for example with a lower dextrose equivalent maltodextrin, a higher carrier ratio or a protein component. Short open-dish exposure at 30 degrees Celsius and 75 per cent relative humidity is a quick screen for caking and colour change. Selected formulations are then placed on accelerated and long-term stability in the final pack, with marker compounds quantified by chromatography and degradation rate constants calculated, together with water activity, flow and caking [6,17,18].

Table 4. Proposed testing sequence for spray-dried botanical powders intended for zone IVb markets.

Stage Tests Decision
Screening of formulations Drying yield; water activity; glass transition by differential scanning calorimetry; flow indices Reject candidates with glass transition close to 30 degrees Celsius at production water activity
Characterisation Sorption isotherm at 30 degrees Celsius; glass transition at several water activities; critical water activity Set maximum water activity for production and packing; choose packaging barrier
Rapid stress screen Open-dish exposure at 30 degrees Celsius and 75 per cent relative humidity for hours to days; caking, colour, flow Identify formulations needing protective packing or reformulation
Accelerated stability 40 degrees Celsius and 75 per cent relative humidity in final pack; marker compounds by chromatography; degradation kinetics Estimate shelf life; compare formulations
Long-term stability 30 degrees Celsius and 75 per cent relative humidity in final pack (semi-permeable packs) for the claimed shelf life Confirm shelf life for registration

9. Minimum reporting standard

The following minimum information is proposed for studies of spray-dried botanical powders intended for commercial use.

  • Extract composition before drying, including solids content and, where relevant, sugar and organic acid content, which drive stickiness.
  • Wall material identity and grade, including dextrose equivalent for maltodextrins and source and certification for gums, starches and proteins, with the carrier-to-extract solids ratio stated once and used consistently.
  • Dryer type and scale, inlet and outlet temperatures, feed rate, feed solids and atomiser settings.
  • Encapsulation efficiency defined explicitly, preferably distinguishing surface from encapsulated active.
  • Moisture content together with water activity, and the glass transition temperature of the powder at its packed water activity.
  • Sorption isotherm and critical water activity at the intended storage temperature.
  • Flow indices interpreted against pharmacopoeial scales, and particle size distribution.
  • Storage stability under the conditions of the climatic zone of sale, in the final pack, with marker compounds quantified and degradation kinetics reported.

10. Conclusions

Encapsulation yield, encapsulation efficiency and morphology at the end of drying are necessary but not sufficient measures of a spray-dried botanical powder. For products sold in hot and very humid markets, the decisive properties are the glass transition temperature at the water activity the powder will actually reach, its sorption behaviour, and the resulting physical and chemical stability at 30 degrees Celsius and 75 per cent relative humidity. Wall materials should be selected on these criteria as well as on drying performance, cost, supply and halal status. The elderberry example shows how a formulation chosen as optimal on fresh-powder data can still have poor flow by pharmacopoeial standards and untested shelf life. Adding sorption, glass transition and climatic-zone storage testing to the standard evaluation would make published formulations directly useful to manufacturers in tropical regions.

References

  1. Gharsallaoui A, Roudaut G, Chambin O, Voilley A, Saurel R. Applications of spray-drying in microencapsulation of food ingredients: an overview. Food Res Int. 2007;40(9):1107–1121.
  2. Díaz-Montes E. Wall materials for encapsulating bioactive compounds via spray-drying: a review. Polymers. 2023;15(12):2659.
  3. Fang Z, Bhandari B. Encapsulation of polyphenols — a review. Trends Food Sci Technol. 2010;21(10):510–523.
  4. Robert P, Fredes C. The encapsulation of anthocyanins from berry-type fruits. Trends in foods. Molecules. 2015;20(4):5875–5888.
  5. Mutavski Z, Vidović S, Lazarević Z, Ambrus R, Motzwickler-Németh A, Aladić K, Nastić N. Stabilization and preservation of bioactive compounds in black elderberry by-product extracts using maltodextrin and gum arabic via spray drying. Foods. 2025;14(5):723.
  6. ASEAN Pharmaceutical Product Working Group. ASEAN guideline on stability study of drug product, version 2.0 (revision 2). Endorsed at the 25th PPWG Meeting; 2018.
  7. Badan Pengawas Obat dan Makanan Republik Indonesia. Peraturan BPOM Nomor 6 Tahun 2025 tentang Pedoman Uji Stabilitas Suplemen Kesehatan. Jakarta: BPOM; 2025.
  8. Bhandari BR, Howes T. Implication of glass transition for the drying and stability of dried foods. J Food Eng. 1999;40(1–2):71–79.
  9. Roos Y, Karel M. Phase transitions of mixtures of amorphous polysaccharides and sugars. Biotechnol Prog. 1991;7(1):49–53.
  10. Rahman MS. State diagram of foods: its potential use in food processing and product stability. Trends Food Sci Technol. 2006;17(3):129–141.
  11. Tonon RV, Baroni AF, Brabet C, Gibert O, Pallet D, Hubinger MD. Water sorption and glass transition temperature of spray dried açai (Euterpe oleracea Mart.) juice. J Food Eng. 2009;94(3–4):215–221.
  12. Kurozawa LE, Park KJ, Hubinger MD. Effect of maltodextrin and gum arabic on water sorption and glass transition temperature of spray dried chicken meat hydrolysate protein. J Food Eng. 2009;91(2):287–296.
  13. Bhandari BR, Datta N, Howes T. Problems associated with spray drying of sugar-rich foods. Dry Technol. 1997;15(2):671–684.
  14. Aguilera JM, del Valle JM, Karel M. Caking phenomena in amorphous food powders. Trends Food Sci Technol. 1995;6(5):149–155.
  15. Caparino OA, Nindo CI, Tang J, Sablani SS. Rheological measurements for characterizing sticky point temperature of selected fruit powders: an experimental investigation. J Food Eng. 2017;195:61–72.
  16. Fongin S, Alvino Granados AE, Harnkarnsujarit N, Hagura Y, Kawai K. Effects of maltodextrin and pulp on the water sorption, glass transition, and caking properties of freeze-dried mango powder. J Food Eng. 2019;247:95–103.
  17. Tonon RV, Brabet C, Hubinger MD. Anthocyanin stability and antioxidant activity of spray-dried açai (Euterpe oleracea Mart.) juice produced with different carrier agents. Food Res Int. 2010;43(3):907–914.
  18. Moreno T, Cocero MJ, Rodríguez-Rojo S. Storage stability and simulated gastrointestinal release of spray dried grape marc phenolics. Food Bioprod Process. 2018;112:96–107.
  19. Jafari SM, Assadpoor E, He Y, Bhandari B. Encapsulation efficiency of food flavours and oils during spray drying. Dry Technol. 2008;26(7):816–835.
  20. Adhikari B, Howes T, Wood BJ, Bhandari BR. The effect of low molecular weight surfactants and proteins on surface stickiness of sucrose during powder formation through spray drying. J Food Eng. 2009;94(2):135–143.
  21. Karim AA, Bhat R. Fish gelatin: properties, challenges, and prospects as an alternative to mammalian gelatins. Food Hydrocoll. 2009;23(3):563–576.
  22. United States Pharmacopeial Convention. General chapter 1174 Powder flow. In: United States Pharmacopeia 38–National Formulary 33. Rockville (MD): USP; 2015.
  23. Castaño Peláez HI, Cortés-Rodríguez M, Ortega-Toro R. Storage stability of a fluidized-bed agglomerated spray-dried strawberry powder mixture. F1000Research. 2023;12:1174.

Declarations

Author contributions

Kuak Ping Ng conceived the review, performed the literature search, analysed the evidence and wrote the manuscript.

Funding

This research received no external funding.

Use of artificial intelligence

An artificial intelligence assistant (Claude, Anthropic) was used to support literature searching, drafting and language editing. The author reviewed, edited and verified all content and references and takes full responsibility for the manuscript.

Data availability

No new data were generated. All data discussed are available in the cited publications.

Disclosure of commercial interest

The author is the owner of the Bionutricia group, a manufacturer of spray-dried botanical extracts and nutraceutical products. No product of the author’s company is evaluated in this review. Nothing in this article is medical advice, and nothing in it claims that any product treats, prevents or cures any condition.

See our ingredient line

Bionutricia Manufacturing Sdn Bhd (201001031866 / 915789-W) © 2026. All Rights Reserved.

Shopping cart

0
image/svg+xml

No products in the cart.

Continue Shopping