
Authors: Ts. Ng Kuak Ping (ORCID 0009-0009-8634-2207) and Dr Yong Yi Yi (ORCID 0009-0004-7507-6496), Research and Development Division, Bionutricia Manufacturing Sdn. Bhd. (Co. No. 201001031866), 37, 39 & 41, Jalan TSB 1, Taman Perindustrian Sungai Buloh, 47000 Sungai Buloh, Selangor, Malaysia
Correspondence: ng@bio-nutricia.com
Article type: Original research article. Preprint of record: Preprints 2026, 202610.2441.
Commercial interest: Bionutricia Manufacturing manufactured all nine extracts tested and sells them as commercial nutraceutical ingredients. See the disclosure section.
Abstract
Botanical extracts are core ingredients of Southeast Asian nutraceuticals, yet comparative data generated under identical laboratory conditions are scarce. This study screened nine botanical extracts — green tea (Camellia sinensis), broccoli (Brassica oleracea var. italica), Brussels sprout (B. oleracea var. gemmifera), pecah beling (Strobilanthes crispus), Sabah snake grass (Clinacanthus nutans), soursop leaf (Annona muricata), noni (Morinda citrifolia), roselle (Hibiscus sabdariffa) and a mixed-berry extract — under identical conditions in a single laboratory. Free-radical scavenging was measured with the 2,2-diphenyl-1-picrylhydrazyl (DPPH) and 2,2′-azino-bis(3-ethylbenzothiazoline-6-sulfonic acid) (ABTS) assays. Green tea extract was the most potent scavenger (half-maximal inhibitory concentration, IC50, 0.8 mg/mL in DPPH and 2.4 mg/mL in ABTS), followed by soursop leaf (1.9 and 5.2 mg/mL). Sabah snake grass, mixed berries, roselle, noni and pecah beling formed a moderate group at roughly one-twentieth to one-fortieth of the potency of green tea, while the two brassica extracts showed little direct scavenging at the solubility limit. Rankings were concordant between the two assays. Untargeted liquid chromatography–quadrupole time-of-flight tandem mass spectrometry of the brassica extracts returned profiles dominated by primary metabolites, consistent with bioactives that act by enzyme induction rather than by direct radical quenching. The results give formulators a uniform single-laboratory basis for comparing these ingredients, and show that chemical scavenging assays alone understate the contribution of brassica extracts.
Keywords: antioxidant capacity; DPPH; ABTS; Clinacanthus nutans; Strobilanthes crispus; Annona muricata; botanical extracts; LC-QTOF-MS/MS; Malaysia
1. Introduction
Plant extracts dominate the ingredient lists of dietary supplements and functional foods in Southeast Asia. Alongside globally traded ingredients such as green tea, broccoli and berry extracts, Malaysian manufacturers use regional herbs with long ethnomedical histories, including Sabah snake grass (Clinacanthus nutans), pecah beling (Strobilanthes crispus), soursop leaf (Annona muricata), noni (Morinda citrifolia) and roselle (Hibiscus sabdariffa) [1–4]. Formulators routinely select between these ingredients on the basis of antioxidant claims, yet published values come from different extraction methods, solvents and assay conditions, which makes them difficult to compare [5].
The DPPH and ABTS radical-scavenging assays are the most widely used first-line measures of antioxidant capacity. They differ in radical chemistry and solvent compatibility — ABTS responds to both hydrophilic and lipophilic antioxidants, whereas DPPH is more selective — so reporting both gives a more robust ranking [5–7].
This study therefore screened nine botanical extracts under identical conditions in a single laboratory using DPPH and ABTS scavenging, and characterised the two brassica extracts by untargeted liquid chromatography–quadrupole time-of-flight tandem mass spectrometry (LC-QTOF-MS/MS). The aim was to provide a uniform comparative benchmark for ingredient selection in nutraceutical formulation.
2. Materials and methods
2.1. Samples
Nine botanical extracts, all supplied as powders, manufactured by Bionutricia Manufacturing Sdn. Bhd., Selangor, Malaysia, were submitted on 14 September 2022 to the Faculty of Applied Sciences, Tunku Abdul Rahman University of Management and Technology (TAR UMT), Kuala Lumpur, where all bioassays were performed as an independent paid analytical service. All extracts were produced under a Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Points and FSSC 22000 certified quality system, and species, plant part, extraction ratio, extraction solvent and declared marker content are those of each product’s released specification. All nine are water extracts, which makes the comparison between them unusually uniform for commercial materials.
Table 1. Samples analysed.
| Sample | Species or composition | Plant part | Ratio | Solvent | Declared marker or active |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Green tea extract | Camellia sinensis (L.) Kuntze | Leaf | 100:1 | Water | Polyphenol |
| Broccoli extract | Brassica oleracea var. italica | Floret | 20:1 | Water | Sulforaphane 0.5–1% |
| Brussels sprout extract | Brassica oleracea var. gemmifera | Sprout leaf | 20:1 | Water | Glucobrassicin |
| Pecah beling extract | Strobilanthes crispus (L.) Blume | Leaf and stem | 100:1 | Water | Phytosterols |
| Sabah snake grass extract | Clinacanthus nutans (Burm.f.) Lindau | Leaf | 100:1 | Water | Stigmasterol |
| Soursop leaf extract | Annona muricata L. | Leaf | 100:1 | Water | Acetogenins 0.01–0.02% |
| Noni extract | Morinda citrifolia L. | Fruit | 100:1 | Water | Scopoletin |
| Roselle extract | Hibiscus sabdariffa L. | Calyx | 5:1 | Water | Anthocyanins 30–50 mg/100 g; phenolics 200–250 mg/100 g |
| Mixed berries extract | Strawberry, blackberry, blueberry, raspberry, cranberry, blackcurrant, redcurrant | Fruit | 20:1 | Water (assumed) | Vitamin C, anthocyanins |
Specification data are taken from each product’s released specification sheet; entries are the versions in force when the samples were submitted. The mixed-berry specification does not state an extraction solvent; water is assumed in line with the other eight. Batch numbers are recorded in the manufacturing records and are available on request.
2.2. Sample preparation
Samples were dissolved in 50% (v/v) dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO). Stock solutions were centrifuged at 5000 rpm for 3 min to remove insoluble material, and the supernatant was diluted with distilled water to the working concentrations. Concentrations are expressed as milligrams of original sample per millilitre. Where limited solubility or intense colour prevented testing above 50 mg/mL, activity at that assay limit is reported.
2.3. DPPH radical-scavenging assay
DPPH scavenging was determined following Brand-Williams et al. [6] as applied by the testing laboratory in its own published work [8]. Briefly, 100 µL of sample solution was mixed with 3.9 mL of 0.6 mmol/L DPPH in methanol and left to stand in the dark at room temperature for 30 min, and absorbance was read at 517 nm against a methanol control. Inhibition (%) = [(Acontrol − Asample)/Acontrol] × 100.
2.4. ABTS radical-cation scavenging assay
ABTS scavenging was determined following Re et al. [7] and Floegel et al. [5]. The ABTS radical cation was generated by reacting 7 mmol/L ABTS with 2.45 mmol/L potassium persulfate and standing in the dark at room temperature for 12–16 h, then diluted with ethanol to an absorbance of 0.70 ± 0.02 at 734 nm; sample was mixed with the working solution, held for 6 min at room temperature and read at 734 nm. Analyses were performed on 21–22 December 2022.
2.5. Untargeted LC-QTOF-MS/MS profiling
Broccoli and Brussels sprout extracts were profiled at the Institute of Systems Biology (INBIOSIS), Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, on a Dionex Ultimate 3000 ultra-high-performance liquid chromatograph coupled to a Bruker MicroTOF QIII. Separation used a Thermo Scientific Acclaim Polar Advantage II C18 column (3 × 150 mm, 3 µm) at 40 °C, flow 0.4 mL/min, injection 3 µL, with 0.1% (v/v) formic acid (A) and methanol (B): 0–3 min 95% A; 3–10 min 20% A; 10–15 min 20% A; 15–22 min 95% A. Electrospray ionisation was operated in negative mode (capillary 4 kV, nebuliser 2 bar, drying gas 8 L/min at 300 °C), scanning m/z 50–1500 with data-dependent tandem acquisition. Features were annotated by accurate mass (error ≤ 8 ppm), adduct and in-source pattern, at Metabolomics Standards Initiative level 3 [9]. Features detected at identical retention time and m/z in every sample matrix were treated as probable system background and excluded; a solvent blank was not available to the authors, so this exclusion rests on the identical retention time, accurate mass and intensity of these features across every sample matrix profiled.
2.6. Data analysis
Results are mean ± standard deviation of three independent replicates (n = 3). IC50 values were estimated from the concentration–response data by linear interpolation between the two concentrations bracketing 50% inhibition. To express potency on a common scale, an ascorbic acid equivalent antioxidant capacity was calculated. A commercial liposomal vitamin C powder analysed by the same laboratory and methods in December 2022 gave IC50 values of 0.12 mg/mL (DPPH) and 0.77 mg/mL (ABTS) on a whole-powder basis. That powder is specified to contain 6500–7500 mg ascorbic acid per 100 g, so a midpoint of 7.0% (w/w) was used to restate the references as ascorbic acid: 0.0084 mg/mL (DPPH) and 0.0539 mg/mL (ABTS). Ascorbic acid equivalent antioxidant capacity was then calculated as (ascorbic acid IC50 / sample IC50) × 1000, and is reported as mg of ascorbic acid per gram of sample. Differences between samples were tested by one-way analysis of variance with the least significant difference post hoc test, with significance set at p < 0.05 (SPSS version 20; IBM, New York, NY, USA).
3. Results
3.1. Free-radical scavenging
Green tea extract was the most potent sample in both assays (IC50 0.8 mg/mL DPPH; 2.4 mg/mL ABTS), followed by soursop leaf extract (1.9; 5.2 mg/mL). Sabah snake grass and mixed berries formed a middle group (DPPH IC50 19.8 and 19.4 mg/mL). Noni reached 50% inhibition only in DPPH (31.6 mg/mL), and pecah beling only in ABTS (36.4 mg/mL). Broccoli and Brussels sprout extracts did not reach 50% inhibition in either assay at the 50 mg/mL solubility limit; Brussels sprout showed no detectable DPPH activity. The rank orders from the two assays were closely concordant: the top two samples were identical, and the brassica extracts were the weakest in both.
Table 2. DPPH and ABTS radical-scavenging activity (% inhibition, mean ± standard deviation), half-maximal inhibitory concentrations and ascorbic acid equivalent antioxidant capacity.
| Sample | DPPH: concentration (mg/mL) → % inhibition | DPPH IC50 (mg/mL) | ABTS: concentration (mg/mL) → % inhibition | ABTS IC50 (mg/mL) | Ascorbic acid equivalent (mg/g) DPPH / ABTS |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Green tea | 0.125 → 12.87 ± 0.55; 0.625 → 41.82 ± 3.68; 1.25 → 74.48 ± 5.02 | ≈0.8 | 1.25 → 28.80 ± 1.77; 2.50 → 51.36 ± 2.86; 50 → 99.80 ± 0.37 | ≈2.4 | 10.5 / 22.5 |
| Soursop leaf | 0.625 → 10.67 ± 2.04; 1.25 → 37.61 ± 3.65; 2.50 → 65.33 ± 3.40 | ≈1.9 | 2.50 → 21.90 ± 1.51; 6.25 → 60.39 ± 2.64 | ≈5.2 | 4.4 / 10.4 |
| Sabah snake grass | 12.5 → 23.76 ± 2.65; 25 → 43.54 ± 5.11; 50 → 56.80 ± 4.76 | ≈19.8 | 12.5 → 31.86 ± 2.05; 25 → 45.31 ± 3.01; 50 → 65.78 ± 1.94 | ≈31.8 | 0.42 / 1.7 |
| Mixed berries | 12.5 → 25.25 ± 2.13; 25 → 44.70 ± 3.08; 50 → 57.15 ± 4.71 | ≈19.4 | 12.5 → 19.51 ± 1.54; 25 → 37.16 ± 1.79; 50 → 65.19 ± 1.81 | ≈37.0 | 0.43 / 1.5 |
| Roselle | 12.5 → 17.73 ± 1.64; 25 → 46.77 ± 3.57; 50 → 61.87 ± 3.97 | ≈26.4 | 50 → 28.11 ± 1.18 | > 50 | 0.32 / — |
| Noni | 12.5 → 32.88 ± 3.13; 25 → 47.77 ± 4.95; 50 → 63.59 ± 3.36 | ≈31.6 | 50 → 42.74 ± 2.94 | > 50 | 0.27 / — |
| Pecah beling | 50 → 26.64 ± 2.70 | > 50 | 12.5 → 22.74 ± 1.53; 25 → 36.83 ± 2.80; 50 → 65.55 ± 3.82 | ≈36.4 | — / 1.5 |
| Broccoli | 50 → 25.19 ± 4.32 | > 50 | 50 → 20.96 ± 1.49 | > 50 | — / — |
| Brussels sprout | 50 → not detected | > 50 | 50 → 11.51 ± 1.54 | > 50 | — / — |
IC50 values are interpolated estimates from the concentration–response data in the laboratory reports. The original report comment for roselle carried another sample’s name; the value shown is the roselle result. Ascorbic acid equivalents are derived as described in section 2.6.
3.2. Putative constituents by LC-QTOF-MS/MS
Annotations that could be supported by accurate mass and adduct pattern are listed in Table 3. Broccoli and Brussels sprout extracts both showed glutamine and, in Brussels sprout, a hexose disaccharide with its dimer and chloride adducts, consistent with free sugars or a sugar-based carrier. Both brassica profiles were dominated by primary metabolites, consistent with their weak direct radical scavenging. A cluster of ions at m/z 713.47, 723.50, 826.56 and 836.59 (product ions m/z 677.50 and 790.58) eluted at 9.0–9.1 min with near-identical intensity in every matrix profiled in this and the companion study, including unrelated samples, and was excluded as probable background. The formula assignments in the original report that contained fluorine or chlorine atoms are not plausible for food-grade plant extracts and were not retained.
Table 3. Putative annotations (negative ionisation; Metabolomics Standards Initiative level 3).
| Sample | Retention time (min) | Observed m/z | Ion | Formula | Error (ppm) | Putative identity |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Broccoli | 1.7 | 145.0619 | [M−H]− | C5H10N2O3 | 0.0 | Glutamine |
| Brussels sprout | 1.7 | 145.0616 | [M−H]− | C5H10N2O3 | −2.1 | Glutamine |
| Brussels sprout | 1.8 | 341.1079 / 377.0853 / 683.2242 | [M−H]− / [M+Cl]− / [2M−H]− | C12H22O11 | −2.9 / −0.8 / −1.3 | Hexose disaccharide |
4. Discussion
Under uniform conditions, green tea and soursop leaf extracts formed a clearly separated high-activity group in both radical-scavenging assays. The concordance of DPPH and ABTS rankings supports the robustness of this grouping despite the different radical chemistries [5]. The regional herbs Sabah snake grass, pecah beling and noni showed moderate activity — roughly 1/20 to 1/40 of green tea on a mass basis — which suggests their traditional use is unlikely to be explained by direct radical scavenging alone [1,4].
The weak direct scavenging of broccoli and Brussels sprout extracts is expected. The principal bioactives of brassicas, glucosinolates and their isothiocyanate derivatives such as sulforaphane, act mainly by inducing endogenous antioxidant and phase II enzymes rather than by quenching radicals directly [11]. Chemical assays therefore underestimate their biological antioxidant contribution, and cell-based or enzyme-induction assays are more appropriate for these ingredients. The released specification for the broccoli extract declares 0.5–1% sulforaphane, so the glucosinolate-derived actives account for at most one part in a hundred of the powder by mass; at that level they would contribute little to a mass-based scavenging assay and would not be expected to appear among the dominant features of a negative-mode mass spectrum.
Limitations
The extracts tested are the authors’ own commercial materials. They are reported as sold rather than matched for active loading: extraction ratios range from 5:1 to 100:1, and declared actives range from 0.01–0.02% (soursop leaf acetogenins) to 0.5–1% (broccoli sulforaphane), with no declared marker at all for green tea or Brussels sprout. A mass-basis ranking therefore compares commercial articles, not equal doses of active constituents. All nine extracts are water extracts, so the comparison is uniform in extraction chemistry but is blind to lipophilic constituents. Antioxidant capacity was referenced to a commercial liposomal vitamin C powder from a parallel batch rather than to a Trolox standard; restating it as ascorbic acid equivalents relies on the specified ascorbic acid content of that powder rather than on a standard curve run alongside the samples. Mass spectrometry was untargeted, negative-mode only, and annotation remained at a putative level. All assays reported here were cell-free; cell-based work is planned for the next phase of testing.
5. Conclusions
Green tea and soursop leaf extracts were the most potent radical scavengers among nine botanical extracts tested under identical conditions, while the two brassica extracts showed little direct activity and returned profiles dominated by primary metabolites. The ranking was concordant between the DPPH and ABTS assays, which supports its use as a uniform benchmark for ingredient selection. For brassica ingredients, chemical scavenging assays understate the likely biological contribution, so enzyme-induction or cell-based assays are the appropriate measure; these, together with Trolox-referenced standardisation and a full concentration–response curve for soursop leaf, are planned for the next phase of testing.
References
- Alam, A.; Ferdosh, S.; Ghafoor, K.; Hakim, A.; Juraimi, A.S.; Khatib, A.; Sarker, Z.I. Clinacanthus nutans: A review of the medicinal uses, pharmacology and phytochemistry. Asian Pac. J. Trop. Med. 2016, 9, 402–409.
- Da-Costa-Rocha, I.; Bonnlaender, B.; Sievers, H.; Pischel, I.; Heinrich, M. Hibiscus sabdariffa L. — A phytochemical and pharmacological review. Food Chem. 2014, 165, 424–443.
- Moghadamtousi, S.Z.; Fadaeinasab, M.; Nikzad, S.; Mohan, G.; Ali, H.M.; Kadir, H.A. Annona muricata (Annonaceae): A review of its traditional uses, isolated acetogenins and biological activities. Int. J. Mol. Sci. 2015, 16, 15625–15658.
- Wang, M.Y.; West, B.J.; Jensen, C.J.; Nowicki, D.; Su, C.; Palu, A.K.; Anderson, G. Morinda citrifolia (Noni): A literature review and recent advances in Noni research. Acta Pharmacol. Sin. 2002, 23, 1127–1141.
- Floegel, A.; Kim, D.-O.; Chung, S.-J.; Koo, S.I.; Chun, O.K. Comparison of ABTS/DPPH assays to measure antioxidant capacity in popular antioxidant-rich US foods. J. Food Compos. Anal. 2011, 24, 1043–1048.
- Brand-Williams, W.; Cuvelier, M.E.; Berset, C. Use of a free radical method to evaluate antioxidant activity. LWT — Food Sci. Technol. 1995, 28, 25–30.
- Re, R.; Pellegrini, N.; Proteggente, A.; Pannala, A.; Yang, M.; Rice-Evans, C. Antioxidant activity applying an improved ABTS radical cation decolorization assay. Free Radic. Biol. Med. 1999, 26, 1231–1237.
- Chuah, H.Q.; Tang, P.L.; Ang, N.J.; Tan, H.Y. Submerged fermentation improves bioactivity of mulberry fruits and leaves. Chin. Herb. Med. 2021, 13, 565–572.
- Sumner, L.W.; Amberg, A.; Barrett, D.; Beale, M.H.; Beger, R.; Daykin, C.A.; et al. Proposed minimum reporting standards for chemical analysis. Metabolomics 2007, 3, 211–221.
- Ng, K.P.; Yong, Y.Y. Antioxidant and in vitro anti-inflammatory screening of ten nutraceutical ingredients: black ginger (Kaempferia parviflora) strongly inhibits heat-induced protein denaturation. Preprints 2026 (companion paper; preprint identifier to be added on posting).
- Fahey, J.W.; Zhang, Y.; Talalay, P. Broccoli sprouts: An exceptionally rich source of inducers of enzymes that protect against chemical carcinogens. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 1997, 94, 10367–10372.
Back matter
Author contributions
Conceptualization, N.K.P.; data curation and formal analysis, N.K.P. and Y.Y.Y.; validation, Y.Y.Y.; writing — original draft, N.K.P.; writing — review and editing, N.K.P. and Y.Y.Y. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
Funding
This research received no external funding. The analyses reported here were commissioned and paid for by Bionutricia Manufacturing Sdn. Bhd.
Data availability
All data generated in this study are contained within the article. The contract analytical reports issued by the testing laboratories are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Acknowledgments
The bioassays were performed as an independent paid analytical service by the Faculty of Applied Sciences, Tunku Abdul Rahman University of Management and Technology, and the mass spectrometry by the Institute of Systems Biology (INBIOSIS), Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia. The authors thank Dr. Tang Pei Ling, Department of Bioscience, Faculty of Applied Sciences, Tunku Abdul Rahman University of Management and Technology, for carrying out the bioassay work.
Disclosure of commercial interest
Both authors are affiliated with Bionutricia Manufacturing Sdn. Bhd., which manufactured all nine extracts tested in this study, sells them as commercial nutraceutical ingredients, and funded the work: N.K.P. is a director of the company and Y.Y.Y. is a member of its Research and Development Division. All bioassays and mass-spectrometric analyses were commissioned as paid independent services from Tunku Abdul Rahman University of Management and Technology and Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, which generated the data reported here and had no role in the interpretation of the results or the decision to publish. The authors declare no other conflict of interest. Nothing in this article is medical advice, and nothing in it claims that any product treats, prevents or cures any condition.
